December 14, 2022 Meeting of Library Assessment Committee

Time and Location of Meeting

December 14, 20229:00 am - 10:00 am Zoom

Agenda Details

Agenda

Community Agreement

  • Listen Actively: Try to understand others before being understood.
  • Step In, Step Back: Step up and use your voice or Step Back and make space for others.
  • Speak from Your Own Lived Experience: Use “I” statements and refrain from telling other people’s stories.
  • Invest In Yourself and Invest in Each Other: Honor our shared space and keep time in mind.
  • Think Beyond Binaries: Hold multiple perspectives at once.
  • Stories Stay, Lessons Go: Confidentiality and personal privacy.
  • Repair Harm: Seek space to repair harm when we mess up.

1. Library Assessment updates (10 min.) 

  • AY 2022-2023 Meeting schedule (in Box)
  • Unit Annual Report Post-Submission Analysis (in progress)
  • Ithaka S+R Faculty Survey (Survey dates: January 30 to February 28, 2023)
  • LibInsight update
  • “After Assessment” (in Box; Research and Assessment Cycle Toolkit https://www.arl.org/research-and-assessment-cycle-toolkit/)

2. Library data request (10 min.)

3. Qualitative methods (30 min.)

  • Belinda
  • Hannah
  • John

4. Thoughts/Questions/Reflections 

Minutes Details

Attendees

Jen-chien Yu, John Laskowski, Belinda Bolivar, Virginia Haverstic, Sandi Caldrone, Hannah Jones, Alex Deeke, Megean Osuchowski, Yali Feng, Mary Ton

Minutes

1. Library Assessment Updates

  • AY 2022-2023 meeting schedule: https://uofi.box.com/s/iy41ll1w9u96qu9kakvx3u7g8b71gtvo
    • Meetings will continue to be virtual
  • Subcommittees:
    • Unit Annual Report Post-Submission Analysis (in progress)
      • 4 teams to review 7 annual reports each w/ content analysis
    • Ithaka S+R Faculty Survey (Survey dates: January 30 to February 28, 2023)
      • Sent to all tenure-track, course instructors for last 2 years, those w/ profiles in Illinois Experts
  • LibInsight update
    • Will replace DeskTracker by July 1, 2023
    • Belinda, Jen, David continuing to lead focus groups with instructors
  • “After Assessment” – Research and Assessment Cycle Toolkit: https://www.arl.org/research-and-assessment-cycle-toolkit/
    • What do we do with the data we collect?
    • Toolkit: Excellent for planning and budgeting, but it is not necessary to always compile results as research paper

2. Library Data Requests

  • Patrons request data for research and projects, come through info desk, take up staff time without serving instruction needs
  • Other data units on campus have policies, groups to review requests
  • Mary, John, Sandi to write exploratory memo for library policy development
  • Consider what data we can make freely available

3. Qualitative Methods

  • Belinda
    • Space observation in GELIC (Grainger Engineering Library Information Center)
    • Goal: more funding for staffing
    • 2 types of observation:
      • Traditional observations – sitting in space for 1 hour
      • Minute observations – staff filling out short form on patron count, noise level, etc.
    • 4 spaces, observed 3 times each
      • Spaces chosen by Megan Sapp-Nelson, head of GELIC – collab areas
      • Times chosen were most active times based on wi-fi data
    • Recruited GELIC GAs to help with observations and wrote observation guide
    • Debrief with observers to assist in compiling observations
    • Content analysis using Atlas TI
    • Tips: Partner with unit, share resources
  • Hannah
    • Practicum on UX with John – bathroom access as factor in library satisfaction with additional concern for trans and gender-non-conforming patrons
    • Participant recruitment: placed banner on library website and flyers in library bathrooms with QR code that linked to page with all 3 instruments, reached out to a couple of student groups on campus
    • 2 online anonymous surveys open to all patrons
      • #1: Free response with option to submit annotated images
      • #2: Short answer prompts: I like…, I want…, I wish…
    • 2 focus groups open to only trans and gender-non-conforming patrons
    • Prioritized anonymity, information security
    • Short-term goals:
      • More accessible info on finding all-gender restrooms on campus
      • Placing free menstrual products in more all-gender restrooms and men’s restrooms
      • Info desk librarians communicating restroom locations quickly and clearly
      • Occupancy indicators on all-gender restrooms
    • Long-term goals:
      • More than one all-gender restroom per building
      • Multi-stall configurations
      • More wheelchair accessibility
      • Increased privacy in stalls (smaller gaps, etc.)
  • John

4. Thoughts/Questions/Reflections